Discussions: Grading Discussions


Grading Discussions

NOTE: Only discussion topics can be graded. Discussion forums cannot be graded.

Students’ discussion posts can only be graded if a topic has been set up as ‘gradable’. For instructions on configuring a topic, visit the Create a Topic page in this resource.

Discussions in Brightspace can be evaluated in two different ways:

  1. You can grade by topic, where you review all comments/replies a student has posted in a topic, and give them an overall grade for their contribution.
  2. You can grade individual posts within a topic, and let Brightspace calculate each student’s overall grade based on the calculation method you had selected when configuring the topic.

1. Grading by Topic

  • Log in to Brightspace and navigate to your course.
  • In the course navbar, click Communication and select Discussions from the dropdown menu.
Discussions in the course navbar
  • Locate the discussion topic you want to grade, and click the downward arrow next to it. Select Assess Topic from the dropdown menu.
Discussions: ‘Assess Topic’ option
  • Locate the name of the student you want to assess and click Topic Score under their name.
    Discussions: ‘Topic Score’ option
  • An evaluation window will open. The window will contain the selected student’s discussion post/posts for this topic. If the topic has a rubric attached to it, you can use it here for evaluation. If you are not using a rubric, manually enter the grade in the Overall Score field and optionally enter feedback in the Overall Feedback field.
Discussions: Topic evaluation window
  • Click Publish or Save Draft at the bottom of the evaluation window to save the grade and feedback.

NOTE: Selecting Publish makes the grade visible to the student whose post (or posts) has just been evaluated, and, if applicable, also sends the grade to the grade book. Thus, the student would receive their grade before other students in the class.

It is recommended that you select Save Draft instead – this option saves the grade and feedback, but does not make it visible to the student. Once you have finished evaluating all students’ posts, you can publish all grades at the same time.

  • Once you have finished evaluating one student, proceed to the next one by using the arrows at the top or bottom of the evaluation window.
Discussions: Navigating between students using arrows

2. Grading Individual Posts

  • Log in to Brightspace and navigate to your course.
  • In the course navbar, click Communication and select Discussions from the dropdown menu.
Discussions in the course navbar
  • Select the discussion topic you want to grade.
Discussions: Selecting a topic to assess
  • Locate the discussion thread you want to grade (a thread = a student’s original post plus any replies to it). Click the arrow next to the thread title and select Assess Student from the dropdown menu.
    Discussions: ‘Assess Student’ option
  • An evaluation window will open. The window will contain the selected student’s discussion post(s) for this topic. Score each individual post, and the system will calculate the Overall Grade according to the calculation method you selected when configuring the topic. If the topic has a rubric attached to it, you can use it here for evaluation. If you wish, add feedback in the Overall Feedback field.
Discussions: Topic evaluation window
  • Click Publish or Save Draft at the bottom of the evaluation window to save the grade and feedback.

NOTE: Selecting Publish makes the grade visible to the student whose post (or posts) has just been evaluated, and, if applicable, also sends the grade to the grade book. Thus, the student would receive their grade before other students in the class.

It is recommended that you select Save Draft instead – this option saves the grade and feedback, but does not make it visible to the student. Once you have finished evaluating all students’ posts, you can publish all grades at the same time.

  • Once you have finished evaluating one student, proceed to the next one by using the arrows at the top or bottom of the evaluation window.
Discussions: Navigating between students using arrows

Publishing Discussion Grades

When you have finished grading all students contributions to a discussion topic, you can publish all their grades at the same time.

  • In the course navbar, click Communication and select Discussions from the dropdown menu.
Discussions in the course navbar
  • Locate the discussion topic you have finished grading, and click the downward arrow next to it. Select Assess Topic from the dropdown menu.
Discussions: ‘Assess Topic’ option
  • At the top of the page, click Publish All Feedback.
    Discussions: ‘Publish All Feedback’ option

Discussions: Group Discussions


Creating Group Discussions

Discussions in Brightspace do not have to involve all students at the same time. Students can be divided into smaller teams (Brightspace groups or course sections) to discuss topics in a more intimate setting. Group discussions can be organized in two different ways:

  1. The same topic can assigned to all students, but students discuss it in smaller groups.
  2. Different groups can be assigned different topics.

For details on how to set up group discussions, click the items below.

> Create one topic for all & separate students into groups using the Discussions tool

NOTE: Groups in Brightspace have to be created prior to this step.

  • Create a discussion topic by following the steps outlined on the Creating a Topic page.
  • Click the Availability Dates and Conditions widget to see available settings.
Discussions: Availability Dates & Conditions
  • Locate the Group and Section Restrictions section and click Manage Restrictions.
Discussions: Manage Restrictions function
  • In the popup window that opens, select Restrict topic and separate the threads. This setting allows you to assign the same topic to all students, but they will discuss it in smaller groups. Each group will only see their own group’s posts.
Discussions: Dividing students into group to discuss a single topic
  • In the same window, go to Group Category or Section. Open the dropdown menu and select the appropriate group category (i.e. the set of groups you have previously created in Brightspace for this task).
Discussions: Selecting a group category or course section
  • Click Add at the bottom of the window. The group restriction will now be visible in the Availability Dates & Conditions widget.
Discussions: Summary of group restrictions in the widget
  • Save your discussion topic.

> Create one topic for all & separate students into groups using the Groups tool

NOTE: The Groups tool does not provide the same flexibility for setting up group discussions as the Discussions tool. If you make an error, you will either have to delete the Group Category and start the process over, or you will have to go to Discussions and make your corrections using that tool.

  • In the course navbar, click Communication and select Groups from the menu.
    Discussions: Groups in the course navbar
  • On the Manage Groups page, click New Category.
    Discussions: Creating a new group category
  • Configure your group category according to your preferences, and scroll down to Additional Options. Select Set up discussion areas.
    Discussions: Setting up discussion in Groups tool
  • You will now be prompted to either create a new discussion forum and/or topic, or link your groups to an existing discussion. Follow the prompts as appropriate to set up your group discussions.
  • When you are finished, your group category will display information about how many discussion topics have been created for each group.
    Discussions: Group discussions in the Groups tool

> Creating different topics for different groups

NOTE: Groups in Brightspace have to be created prior to this step.

  • Create a discussion topic by following the steps outlined on the Creating a Topic page.
  • Click the Availability Dates and Conditions widget to view available options.
Discussions: Availability Dates & Conditions
  • Locate the Group and Section Restrictions section and click Manage Restrictions.
    Discussions: Group & Section Restrictions
  • In the popup window that opens, select Restrict topic. This setting allows you to assign a topic to a specific group of students.
Discussions: Group & Section Restrictions
  • Open the dropdown menu located just below, and select the appropriate group. (Remember: Groups have to be created prior to this step.)
Discussions: Assigning a topic to a specific group
  • Click Add at the bottom of the window. The group restriction will now be visible in the Availability Dates & Conditions widget.
Discussions: Availability Dates & Conditions
  • Save your discussion topic.

Discussions: Creating a Forum


Creating a Discussion Forum

NOTE: Students cannot post in a discussion forum alone. For students to be able to post, a discussion topic has to be created within a forum.

To create a discussion forum:

  • Log in to Brightspace and navigate to your course.
  • In the course navbar, click Communication and select Discussions from the dropdown menu.
Discussions in the course navbar
  • Click New and select New Forum from the dropdown menu.
Discussions: Creating a new forum
  • A New Forum page will open. It contains two tabs – Properties and Restrictions. For details on the settings available in each tab, see the menu below the image.
Discussions: Forum properties and restrictions

1. Properties tab

  • By default, ‘New Forum’ page opens on the Properties tab. Here, enter the Title for your forum. Directly underneath the title, you can find the option to ‘Create a new topic with the same title’ as the forum. Select if appropriate.
Discussions: Forum title
  • Enter the forum Description (optional).
Discussions: Forum description
  • Review the Options listed at the bottom of the page and decide whether you wish to apply any of them to the forum.
Discussions: Forum options

The options are:

  • Allow anonymous posts – Select if you want to allow students to post without revealing their name. As an instructor, you will always be able to see who authored each post.
  • Users must start a thread before they can read and reply to other threads in each topic – Select if you want students to create an original post before they can see other students’ posts.
  • A moderator must approve individual posts before they display in the forum – Select if you want to manually approve each student’s post before others in the class can see it.
  • Display forum description in topics – Select if you want the forum description to be repeated in each topic created in the forum. If you plan to have multiple topics in a forum, a better option is for each topic to have its own description.

Save the forum.

2. Restrictions tab

NOTE: Setting restrictions at the level of a forum is optional. Alternatively, you can set restrictions for the topics you will create in the forum (the same restriction types are available).

  • At the top of a New/Edit Forum page, go to the Restrictions tab.
Discussions: Restrictions tab in a forum

Here you can set these optional parameters:

  • Hide from Users – Selecting this option makes a forum invisible to students. You can hide a forum while you are still developing it, but you are not yet ready to share it with students. When you are ready to share a forum with the class, you need to manually unselect this setting.
Discussions: Hiding a forum
  • Availability Dates – You can set a Start and an End Date for a forum and thus make it available to students only for a period of time. If you apply one or both availability dates, you should also select the Display in Calendar option so that students can see the dates in the course calendar.

NOTE: Please review the visibility options associated with the Start and End Dates carefully. For example, if you want to restrict access to a forum until a certain date, but also want to leave the forum open for students to view even after the discussion has ended, the best options would be:

Visible with access restricted with Start Date, and
Visible with submission restricted with End Date.

Discussions: Adding availability dates to a forum
  • Release Conditions can be applied.
  • Group and Section Restrictions – You can restrict the forum to a specific group or section within the course.
Discussions: Setting group restrictions
  • Click Save and Close at the bottom of the page.

Video Instructions

The video below illustrates how to create a discussion forum.

Discussions: Creating a topic


Creating a Discussion Topic

NOTE: Students cannot post in a discussion forum alone. To allow students to post, a discussion topic has to be created within a forum.

To create a discussion topic, follow the steps below.

  • Log in to Brightspace and navigate to your course.
  • In the course navbar, click Communication and select Discussions from the dropdown menu.
Discussions in the course navbar
  • Click New and select New Topic from the dropdown menu.
Discussions: Creating a topic
  • A New Topic page will open. The page contains four sections, as marked in the image below. For details on what settings are available in each section, please refer to the menu below the image.
Discussions: Topic creation/editing page

A. Topic Details & Grading Options

  • Enter the title in the Topic Title field.
Discussions: Topic Title field
  • Decide whether you want to assign the topic to an already existing forum or create a new forum.
Discussions: Adding topic to an existing forum vs. Creating a new forum
  • If you are not planning to grade students’ posts for this topic, leave the Grade Out Of as Ungraded (the default setting).
Discussions: Default setting for grading a topic
  • If you are planning to grade students’ posts for this topic, click the box under Grade Out Of box and enter the maximum score students can get for the task.
  • The next step depends on the status of your Brightspace grade book.
    1. Scenario #1: Your Brightspace grade book is NOT set up
      If you have not previously created a grade item for this discussion topic in the grade book, no further action is needed in this section. When you click Save at the bottom of the page, the system will automatically create a corresponding grade book item with the same title as the discussion topic.
Discussions: Creating a new grade item for a topic
  1. Scenario #2: Your Brightspace grade book IS set up
    If you have previously created a grade item for this discussion topic in the grade book, you want to link the two at this point. To do so, click In Grade Book, and select Edit or Link to existing from the menu. Follow the prompts to link the topic to the appropriate grade book item.
Discussions: Linking the topic to an existing grade book item
  1. Other options available upon entering a score in the Grade Out Of box are:
    • Not in Grade Book – this option allows you to assign a score to the discussion topic, but without creating a grade item in the grade book.
    • Reset to Ungraded – this option deletes the score you had entered and restores the default setting of Ungraded.
Discussions: Additional grading options

B. Availability Dates & Conditions (optional)

In this section, you can set the following parameters:

  • Availability Dates – You can set a Start and an End Date for your topic, and thus make it available to students only for a period of time. If you apply one or both availability dates, you should also select the Add availability dates to Calendar option so that students can see the dates in the course calendar.
Discussions: Availability Dates & visibility

NOTE: Visibility options associated with the Start and End Dates should be applied carefully. For example, if you want to restrict access to a topic details until a certain date, but you also want to leave the topic open for students to view even after the discussion has ended, the best options would be:
1. Visible with access restricted with Start Date, and
2. Visible with submission restricted with End Date.

  • Release Conditions can be attached to the topic.
  • Group and Section Restrictions can be applied. This setting allows you to divide students into smaller teams (groups or course sections) for the discussion. You can organize group discussions in two different ways:
    1. You can assign each group a different topic. To do this, select Restrict topic and choose the specific group that should discuss the topic you are creating.
    2. You can assign the same discussion topic to the whole class, but each group would only see their own group’s posts. To do this, select Restrict topic and separate the threads and then choose the relevant Group Category or Section.

NOTE: Groups have to be created prior to this step.

Discussions: Group restriction options

C. Post & Completion Settings

In this section, you can select one of the following settings:

  • Default participation – Students can post and view other students’ posts without any restrictions.
  • Allow learners to hide their name from other learners – Students have the option to post anonymously.
  • Learners must start a thread before they can view or reply to other threads – Students cannot view anyone else’s posts until they add an original post.
  • Posts must be approved before they display in the topic – The instructor has to manually approve each student’s post before it becomes visible to the whole class.
Discussions: Post & Completion options

D. Evaluation & Feedback Settings

In this section, you can set the following evaluation parameters:

  • You can add a rubric in order to share evaluation criteria with students and later use to grade their posts.
Discussions: Adding a rubric to a topic
  • If the topic will be graded, and if students can add more than one discussion post, instructors have the option to score each post separately. If you choose this option, you can select how the individual scores should contribute to the students’ overall score for the task (e.g., average of all scores, highest score only etc.).
Discussions: Evaluation of individual posts
  • You can allows students to rate each other’s posts. Several rating schemes are available for this purpose: five-star rating, up/down vote rating, up-vote only rating.
    Discussions: Allowing students to rate each other’s posts

Discussions: Terminology


Discussions Terminology

There are a few terms essential to understanding how discussions in Brightspace are structured.

Forum
  • A discussion forum is a collection of related discussion topics, similar to a category in Assignments and Quizzes.
  • There may be several discussion forums in a course, and each forum may contain one or several topics.
  • A forum cannot be graded, and thus it cannot be linked to the grade book.
  • A forum cannot have a rubric attached to it.
  • Students cannot post in a forum unless it contains a topic.
Topic
  • Once a forum is created, an instructor has to add a topic (or topics) to it.
  • A discussion topic is a place where students post their responses to a question/prompt and reply to other students’ posts.
  • Topics have to be created within a forum – they cannot exist independently.
  • Topics can be graded, and can be linked to the grade book.
  • A rubric can be attached to a topic for evaluation purposes.
Thread
  • A thread is created when a student posts in a discussion topic. A discussion thread consists of the original post along with any replies to that post.
  • There are often multiple threads per topic (each student may start their own thread).
Reply
  • A reply is a response to another student’s post in a thread.
Post
  • A discussion post refers to any message posted in a thread.

NOTE: Students cannot create discussion forums or topics. They can only start threads and reply to posts. Thus, the discussion area has to be set up by the instructor.

Example

The image below illustrates the different elements of a discussion in Brightspace.

Discussions forum, topics, threads, and posts

Discussions: Introduction


Discussions: Introduction

The Discussions tool in Brightspace provides students with a space to communicate with one another by posting, reading, and replying to messages. Instructors can create discussion forums to allow students to:

  • Ask questions about the course, assessments etc.
  • Comment and share reflections on course material
  • Collaborate in groups (e.g., on a group project)
  • Discuss answers to an assignment
  • Share files with the whole class or group (e.g., PPT presentations or articles)

Discussions in Brightspace can be open to the entire class or restricted to smaller groups. Group discussions can be set up in two ways: each group can discuss the same topic in a private setting, or different topics can be assigned to different groups. Also, when teaching a course with combined course sections, section-specific discussions can be created. Instructors can also create discussions where students can post anonymously.

NOTE: Students are not able to create discussion forums or topics. Instructors need to structure the discussion area for students.

Benefits of Using Discussions

There are many benefits of incorporating discussions into a course. Discussions can:

  • promote communication and collaboration among students,
  • provide a platform where students can learn from each other and co-create knowledge,
  • give each student an equal opportunity to share their ideas,
  • provide a comfortable place to share ideas to shy or introverted students, who may be reluctant to speak in a classroom,
  • allow students to practice writing skills (although they should not be treated as writing assignments but dialogues).

Video Overview

The following short video introduces the basic how-tos of the Discussion Tool.

You may also wish to download a copy of the Discussions Guide for Instructors (PDF) to your device.