The age of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is upon us. While it opens many possibilities, it also presents some less desirable challenges to the assessment of learning in higher education. This resource reviews ten GenAI-resilient assessment designs for you to consider adopting in your course.
Categories of GenAI Resilient Assessments
The examples below may be suitable for professors who do not want students to rely on or use GenAI as the answer to the questions, problems, written research, etc., they are assigned to complete. The examples below can be thought of as being GenAI resilient in two distinct ways:
- Assignments where factors such as mode of delivery, the type of work required, the specific mediums to be used, etc., all contribute to GenAI as either not useable at all, or not of any practical value. These are ones where they ‘can’t use GenAI’ meaningfully.
- Assignments where the instructor wants students to not feel the need or drive to use GenAI even if it is, technically, possible to do so. Here, the focus is on assignments where students on their own accord recognize that they have no reason to rely on GenAI to solve the task at hand. Here, students would ‘not consider using GenAI’ at all.
General Examples
1.In-Class Handwritten Essays
Description: These require students to develop ideas in real time, which makes it easier to see their own reasoning, writing ability, and grasp of course concepts.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: They are effective because they reveal how well students can interpret a question, organize an argument, and support claims without outside assistance.
Ideal Mode of Delivery: Naturally this is more suitable for in-class delivery mode, whether handwritten or typed.
2. Oral Presentations
Description: Students present an interpretation, argument, or research finding to the class in real time.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: This is effective because it assesses understanding, communication skills, and the ability to explain complex ideas clearly. It also allows instructors to ask follow-up questions that test depth of knowledge.
Ideal Mode of Delivery: This is most likely done in-class but can also be incorporated as live (synchronous) real-time presentations using either Online Rooms or WebEx, both of which are integrated in Brightspace.
3. Seminar discussion Leadership
Description: Students take responsibility for guiding discussion on a text, theme, or issue.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: Seminar Discussions of this sort can show whether students can identify important ideas, pose thoughtful questions, and connect readings to broader course goals. It also highlights preparation and intellectual engagement stressing the ongoing process of learning rather than solely focusing on the product.
Ideal Mode of Delivery/Examples: This is well-suited for online/Brightspace integration in the Discussion Forum.
4. Close Reading Exercises
Description: Students analyze a short passage from a literary, philosophical, historical, cultural text, or course notes provided by the instructor.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: This is especially effective in humanities and social science courses as it focuses on interpretation, attention to detail, and evidence-based analysis. It also reveals whether students can work carefully with language and meaning. To further discourage reliance on GenAI, provided readings could be from material that are less likely to have been used by large language models, such as instructor-created notes, lecture content, class discussions, concepts and ideas covered exclusively in class, etc.
Ideal Mode of Delivery/Examples: More suited for in-class but can also be done online either through a live discussion or live shared documents, timed, etc.
5. Reading & Writing Journals
Description: Students write regular ‘reflections’ on course readings. Instead of producing a single piece, they ‘personally’ reflect on their understanding in an ongoing manner.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: These are effective because they make learning visible over time and encourage consistent engagement. Journals can often show how students are processing ideas, raising questions, and building connections across the course.
Ideal Mode of Delivery/Example: Though well suited for in-class completion, this could be completed online. Assignment design should encourage students to reduce their reliance on GenAI while demonstrating the development of their reading, writing, and critical thinking skills. Students could write through a shared, ‘ongoing’ document (e.g. Google Docs, OneDrive, etc.), where the writing process and revision history are visible, or in a single-member discussion forum that documents the development of their thinking over time. These approaches emphasize the learning process as well as the final product.
6. Short Response Papers
Description: These brief assignments ask students to respond to a reading, question, or concept.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: They are effective because they promote frequent practice in analysis and argumentation without the pressure of a major paper. They also help instructors check understanding early and often.
Ideal Mode of Delivery: Best suited for in-class but can be done for online courses in an invigilated manner or via live online rooms, Bongo, etc.
7. Annotated Bibliographies
Description: Students identify and briefly evaluate sources related to a topic.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: This is effective because it assesses research skills, source selection, and the ability to understand scholarly conversations. It helps students learn how knowledge is built across the various disciplines,
Ideal Mode of Delivery: For fully invigilated assessment this naturally works best in-class but can also be done online in a shared manner, ongoing document, etc.
8. Text Based Exams
Description: Exams can include passage identification, interpretation, concept explanation, or short essays based on course materials.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: These are effective because they measure understanding, critical thinking and the ability to synthesize ideas under controlled conditions. They are particularly useful when tied closely to specific texts or course notes studied in class that are very specific to the instructor’s approach or position on the given topics.
Ideal Mode of Delivery: In-class or online.
9. Research Proposals
Description: Instead of only grading a final essay, instructors assess the student’s topic, question, thesis, and plan for evidence.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: This is effective because it captures the thinking process behind research and writing. It allows instructors to see whether students can frame a meaningful inquiry before completing the full project.
Ideal Mode of Delivery: Either online or in person.
10. Portfolios with Reflection
Description: Students collect several pieces of work over the term and include a reflection on their learning.
Why/How is it effective in relation to AI Use: This is effective because it emphasizes growth, revision, and metacognition (self-awareness). It gives a fuller picture of student development than a single assignment and helps students recognize how their thinking has changed.
Ideal Mode of Delivery: Could work quite well online (in Brightspace) where students show or share their reflections on their work or learning process.
Example of a GenAI-Resilient Assessment
Let’s look at an example from a Human Kinetics and Recreation (HKR) course group assignment focused on academic integrity and academic misconduct. This assignment is an example of a productive approach to GenAI in higher education: it neither bans the use of GenAI nor treats it as a shortcut. Rather, it teaches students to use GenAI transparently, critically, and ethically and responsibly.
About the Assignment
In this assignment, students will treat GenAI both as an object of study and as a tool for practice. Students are not simply permitted to use AI; they are required to examine how AI tools work, what they can and cannot do, and how they can be used ethically in academic contexts. This approach moves the assignment beyond the usual “AI allowed” policy by making the use of GenAI a core part of the structured learning activity, required to respond to the task. Students must select two AI tools, evaluate their capabilities and limitations, demonstrate responsible use, and show how AI-generated content can be properly attributed and integrated into original academic work, all of which culminate in a thorough real-world applied understanding of academic honesty, integrity, and transparency.
Key strengths (and pedagogical value) of the GenAI integration include:
- AI use is intentional, not incidental: Students are asked to actively explore AI tools rather than use them casually or secretly.
- Students evaluate AI critically: The assignment requires them to consider benefits, risks, limitations, and ethical concerns.
- Responsible use is demonstrated: Students must create a sample document using AI and show how to cite sources and handle AI-generated content appropriately.
- AI literacy is built into the assessment: Students learn not only how to use AI tools, but also how to judge when and how those tools are appropriate.
- Academic integrity remains central: The assignment connects AI use directly to plagiarism, misconduct, attribution, originality, etc.
- Students learn through practice: By demonstrating common GenAI pitfalls and risks as well as how to avoid them, students can develop hands-on practical strategies for ethical AI use (beyond the scope of the assignment itself).
- Reflection is embedded: The assignment asks students to consider the personal, academic, and professional importance of integrity when using AI.
Note:
This resource was developed using presentation materials used in CITL Teaching Development Days 2026.
Originally Published: September 10, 2026



